A history of ear tubes to treat infections does not appear to adversely affect children with cochlear implants, regardless of whether the tubes are left in place or removed before implantation, according to a report in the June issue of Archives of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, one of the JAMA/Archives journals, Chicago.

Newborn hearing screening is now widespread and cochlear implants to reverse hearing loss have been shown to be successful in children younger than age 2, according to background information in the article. As a result, children are increasingly identified as candidates for cochlear implants near the peak age for developing acute otitis media, or middle ear infection.

Myringotomy tubes, placed in the middle ear after a small incision is made in the eardrum, have been a mainstay of treatment of otitis media for children with normal hearing. However, they are avoided by some surgeons for children who have or are candidates for cochlear implants because of concerns about increased complications.

Christopher F. Barañano, MD, and colleagues at the University of Alabama at Birmingham Medical School studied 78 ears of 62 children (average age 3.2) who received ear tubes before cochlear implants. In 46 (59%) of the cases, the tubes were removed before cochlear implantation surgery, whereas in 32 cases (41%), the tubes were kept in place until cochlear implantation.

Forty ears (51%) received more than one set of tubes; 10 ears (22%) in which the tubes were removed before cochlear implant surgery required additional tubes later, compared with six ears (19%) in which the tubes remained in place.

All eardrums in which the tubes were removed before or during cochlear implantation healed. Three persistent eardrum perforations required surgical treatment. However, there were no cases of meningitis or removal of cochlear implants because of infection, according to the researchers.

"The minimization of potential infectious complications is a priority for the cochlear implant surgeon who is operating on a child with a history of myringotomy tube placement," the authors write. "While manipulation of the tympanic membrane [eardrum] with myringotomy tube insertion, myringotomy tube exchange or perforation repair is not without risks, in the current study the management of the myringotomy tube before cochlear implantation did not adversely affect outcomes."

Cases of otorrhea–discharge from the ear–and eardrum perforation were successfully managed with standard surgical and medical therapies and typically did not require more extensive procedures. "Specific myringotomy tube management over the course of cochlear implantation does not appear to adversely affect the final outcomes in cases involving pediatric ears," the writers conclude.

Journal Reference:
Christopher F. Baranano; Richard S. Sweitzer; Mandy Lutz Mahalak; Nathan S. Alexander; Audie L. Woolley. The Management of Myringotomy Tubes in Pediatric Cochlear Implant Recipients. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 2010; 136 (6): 557-560

[Source: JAMA & Archives]