Researchers from the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences (UAMS) evaluated the accuracy of differing hearing screening tools in a rural school setting in a recent article published Ear and Hearing, the official journal of the American Auditory Society.

Samantha Kleindienst Robler, AuD, PhD, (left) and Susan Emmett, MD, MPH

Samantha Kleindienst Robler, AuD, PhD, associate director of the UAMS Center for Hearing Health Equity, was the lead author of the article titled, “Changing the Paradigm for School Hearing Screening Globally: Evaluation of Screening Protocols From Two Randomized Trials in Rural Alaska.”

Susan Emmett, MD, MPH, director of the center, was the senior author leading 11 co-authors on the article, which reportedly cited data collected during a study that Robler and Emmett led in 2017-2020 in 15 communities in rural northwest Alaska.

The research team evaluated the accuracy of several screening tools for detecting hearing loss and middle ear disease in rural Alaskan children from preschool to 12th grade, including mobile health (mHealth) pure-tone screening, distortion product optoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) and tympanometry.

According to Robler and Emmett, tympanometry—an objective test of middle ear health—was an essential tool for detecting infection-related hearing loss common in rural environments, increasing sensitivity by nearly 20% when combined with pure-tone screening and 10% when combined with DPOAE, an objective screen for hearing used with younger children.

“Both the mHealth pure-tone screen and the DPOAE screen performed better when tympanometry was added to the protocol,” the researchers explained. “Tympanometry is a key component in the hearing screening protocol, particularly in environments with higher prevalence of infection-related hearing loss.”

The team also explained that their research found that “High-frequency mHealth pure-tone screen with tympanometry was the superior tool for children 7 years and older. For children 3 to 6 years of age, DPOAE plus tympanometry performed the best.”

According to the researcher, despite these results, adding tympanometry to a screening program in rural and underserved areas may prove challenging. Commercially available tympanometers are expensive and designed to be used by highly trained audiologists. To address this gap, Robler and Emmett received a $50,000 pilot grant from the UAMS Translational Research Institute to assist in their ongoing efforts to develop a low-cost, cell phone-based tympanometer to detect problems in the middle ear.

The team shared that their goal of this project  is to encourage uniform, routine screenings by schools and community health workers to better identify children who are at risk of developing infection-related hearing loss or who have already developed it but haven’t been diagnosed, as part of an ultimate effort to reduce childhood hearing loss.

“Infection-related hearing loss often goes undetected in children, particularly those in rural communities who lack easy access to health care,” commented Robler. “It is a leading cause of preventable hearing loss, which affects speech and language development, learning ability and the ability to find a job. This is why we chose to focus on the best methods for easily and accurately identifying childhood hearing loss.”

Sixty percent of hearing loss in children is preventable, according to the World Health Organization, and this estimate rises to 75% in underserved communities where infection-related hearing loss is most common.

“No work to-date has evaluated screening tools on such a scale, and the implications for how it will inform guidelines and policy is significant,” Robler described.  “We anticipate that this paper will change how school screening is performed in rural and underserved communities across the U.S. and abroad, improving identification of infection-related childhood hearing loss in regions of the world most affected by the lifelong implications of this preventable and treatable health disparity,” Emmett added.

Source: Linda Satter, University of Arkansas Medical Sciences

Images: University of Arkansas Medical Sciences